The Supreme Court is seen in Washington, Nov. 2, 2024. Credit: J. Scott Applewhite / AP Photo

This story is published by agreement with The Associated Press. It may not be republished without the express permission of The Associated Press.  

This story also appeared in

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Tuesday turned back an election law case out of Montana that relied on a controversial legal theory with the potential to change the way elections are run across the country.

The high court declined to hear the case in a brief order without explaining its reasoning, as is typical.

Montana was appealing a ruling that struck down two GOP-backed election laws. It’s relying on the independent state legislature theory, which holds that state judges shouldn’t be allowed to consider election cases at all.

Montana Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen argues that only lawmakers have sway over state elections under the U.S. Constitution. She asked the justices to consider the case after the state’s highest court struck down laws ending same-day voter registration and prohibiting paid ballot collection.

The Montana Democratic Party, joined by tribal organizations and youth groups, argued the laws made it more difficult for Native Americans, new voters, the elderly and those with disabilities to vote.

Courts found the laws violated the rights of voters as protected under the state Constitution.

The Supreme Court largely rejected the independent state legislature theory in a 2023 case known as Moore v. Harper. That case out of North Carolina focused on a legal argument that electoral maps can’t be challenged in court.

Still, the opinion left the door open for more legal wrangling by indicating there could be limits on state court efforts to police elections.

LATEST STORIES

A bowl of sunshine for soup season

In the final few months of 2024, we didn’t see a lot of big snowfalls or crisp temperatures. But the start of 2025 has provided us with ample reasons to ramp up soup season. This curried cauliflower soup is a delicious option to slurp today or stash in your icebox for later.

Lawmakers ponder bills aimed at narrowing ag property tax loopholes

A pair of bills aimed at closing loopholes that may make it too easy for Montana property owners to qualify for hefty property tax benefits intended for farms and ranches got their initial hearings before the Montana Legislature this week, drawing hours of commentary from supporters and opponents.